Galaxy Legion Forum :: View topic - Request new alert rules for Legion Combat

Excelcier wrote:

If a player is going after red badges and yellow badges hits a player that doesn't like it and they retaliate; the attacking player now has the ability to alert that player who was originally attacked to his entire legion. So? There'll always be jerks, can't do anything about that.

Some of you are assuming that the player being attacked is the only aggressor by stealing a planet or some other type of action. No... this is for all alerts

The current alerting system does not allow for an equal type ability to respond. War is never equal

It is a one sided response. the alerted can fight back if they want to

I am not asking for LESS ability to fight; I am asking for more ability to fight those who want to go at it. then toss a cm at them and you two can go at it how ever long you'd like. alert each other and get the whole legion involved.

Yes, there are legions who want to fight each other; there are those who don't.

That was why I had the suggestion for "legion wars" tab by an officer or leader of a legion. We want only certain people doing certain things with the legion.

Let's even look at the mutual aspect of each side wanting to fight -- If one side "declares war" on the other; have an "accept legion war" by the other side. And if the other side doesn't want to fight? They just decline the war?

The simple solution here is that those two legions then only have the other legion on their BT; this would make it an overall minimal change for Dan to make; yes, we would be limited to only 10 on the other side, unless Dan would expand the player participation on the BT screens. The simple solution is to have your legion find one of the other legion on their bt, get alerted and then slowly alert the whole legion until you guys all have each other on your news feed. No need for Dan to add a feature that can easily be worked around already.

A solution for those who do not want to participate is also have a participation button in the player profile that says "participate in wars" if clicked; they are put into the mix; however this button cannot be changed except once you are in; you have to stay in for a minimal of one week and if you "opt out of the wars" you cannot participate again for another week like the base attacks if you change legions or leave for a short time to help out another legion. This will discourage players from getting in; finding out they get hit a lot and "don't want to ruin their stats" and run away; then come back to hit a few times and leave and use the "opt out" as a protection against their aggression. Halcyons work too.

Author:	Excelcier [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:05 am ]
Post subject:	Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
I think the alert rules should be modified. Currently we cannot alert a second player for a 12 hour period. I think a modificaion should be made for alerts within the same legion on players who attack all at once. The lack of current ability to alert the attacking players puts the attacked player and a huge disadvantage. The rules should be that make sense. If a legion is attacking a player in another legion and there are several of those players attacking; the attacked player should be able to alert ALL of those players to his legion for defense. The current system allows for too much advantage on the attacking legion players to allow for gang banging players. Two things could or should remedy this type of action. First, it is usually one legion against another; so there should be a tab for "Legion Wars" making each legion total fair and open game to the other; instead of only being able to alert one player at a time when being attacked by 4,6,7 or more without the ability to respond in kind from a coordinated attack. There should be an additional option tab; it says "Declare War on XXXXX Legion" by a leader or officer; which would allow full combat mode for any and all players in the legions. This will have two fold effect. First, opens up the entire legion to consequences of a rogue player or two; and second will keep checks and balances of legions who have players who don't want a lot of combat. They would need to transfer to another legion if one is very aggressive and others who are in a passive legion may need to look for a more aggressive legion. The details can be worked out to qualifcations for legion combat status by input from others. However this should be an addition to this type of game. Excelcier.

Author:	ZeroEither [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:08 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
No Eggy stop complaining take your war whoopin like a man.

Author:	Excelcier [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:12 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
Zero, One on one is a fair fight; one you lose too often; 5,6 or more on one is not a fair fight.... let's bring all the firepower to the table. Excelcier

Author:	keithor [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:17 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
ZeroEither wrote: No Eggy stop complaining take your war whoopin like a man. thats funny coming from you

Author:	ZeroEither [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:17 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
You know what else isnt a fair fight eggy... someone over 200 ranks higher then yah, so quit complaining its called war and i take my whoopin like a man and dont complain on the forums about it.

Galaxy Legion Forum http://galaxylegion.com/forum/

Request new alert rules for Legion Combat http://galaxylegion.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=25109	Page 1 of 2

Author:	Excelcier [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:25 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
Zero, the only time you disable us is when we are off line; else we simply zero you out.... talk all ya want.....

Author:	ZeroEither [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:28 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
The same goes for you Eggy and i'm hardly offline for you to 0 me Closest i'v been this entire time is 0 2 1, to my memory so why not come at me instead of sittin here on the forums, i'd come at your not on my scans right now =( and keithor is down so... or maybe i'll take down teneka again.

Author:	johnny blade [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:30 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
I don't know which ship that has engaged in the NI-CN conflict that has not been alerted at least once... I think the problem you are experiencing isn't one of game limitations but rather of your own personal shortcomings... this often happens when you can't understand normal thinking.

Author:	keithor [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:35 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
not sure why this has been derailed but I think a legion war option would be great leave the details up to Dan

Author:	ZeroEither [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:38 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
Legion war option would be sweet set a specific legion, maybe even a time limit, makes enemy legion spawn more often in your bt yada yada.

Author:	keithor [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:53 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
ZeroEither wrote: Legion war option would be sweet set a specific legion, maybe even a time limit, makes enemy legion spawn more often in your bt yada yada. look at that Cosa and ni agreeing on something lol

Author:	ZeroEither [ Tue May 22, 2012 2:56 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
its called civility... some of us can tune from aggressive to civil those are the ones that understand its just a game

Author:	Preliator Xzien [ Tue May 22, 2012 3:00 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
This is quite the suggestion

Author:	Vyger [ Tue May 22, 2012 3:20 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
Xzien wrote: This is quite the suggestion Yeah yeah, Mr Rolly Eyes, but we still don't have it, and we don't even know if it's a priority for Dan. Cripes, this is light-years ahead of the trading hub as a priority in my view: trading works fine today, wars don't.

Page 1 of 2	All times are UTC
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group https://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	ZeroEither [ Tue May 22, 2012 3:24 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
Xzien wrote: Vyger wrote: Xzien wrote: This is quite the suggestion Yeah yeah, Mr Rolly Eyes, but we still don't have it, and we don't even know if it's a priority for Dan. Cripes, this is light-years ahead of the trading hub as a priority in my view: trading works fine today, wars don't. Then here's an idea. War Pact. It's been suggested many times. Thumbs Up.

Author:	KJReed [ Tue May 22, 2012 3:50 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
war pact doesnt exactly work though. thats assuming both sides want the war. and no you shouldnt be able to alert everyone attacking you. if you did something to get alerted.... well you're gonna have to deal with it. This aint farmville. If you steal a planet or something you're gonna have to deal with anyone and everyone in that legion beating up on you for as long as they can alert you.

Author:	Preliator Xzien [ Tue May 22, 2012 9:22 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
KJReed wrote: war pact doesnt exactly work though. thats assuming both sides want the war. and no you shouldnt be able to alert everyone attacking you. if you did something to get alerted.... well you're gonna have to deal with it. This aint farmville. If you steal a planet or something you're gonna have to deal with anyone and everyone in that legion beating up on you for as long as they can alert you. For a while in the beginning you could alert anyone. Guess what: Dan changed it. So do you guys really think he'll change it back?

Author:	Excelcier [ Tue May 22, 2012 11:11 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
If a player is going after red badges and yellow badges hits a player that doesn't like it and they retaliate; the attacking player now has the ability to alert that player who was originally attacked to his entire legion. Some of you are assuming that the player being attacked is the only aggressor by stealing a planet or some other type of action. The current alerting system does not allow for an equal type ability to respond. It is a one sided response. I am not asking for LESS ability to fight; I am asking for more ability to fight those who want to go at it. Yes, there are legions who want to fight each other; there are those who don't. That was why I had the suggestion for "legion wars" tab by an officer or leader of a legion. We want only certain people doing certain things with the legion. Let's even look at the mutual aspect of each side wanting to fight -- If one side "declares war" on the other; have an "accept legion war" by the other side. The simple solution here is that those two legions then only have the other legion on their BT; this would make it an overall minimal change for Dan to make; yes, we would be limited to only 10 on the other side, unless Dan would expand the player participation on the BT screens. A solution for those who do not want to participate is also have a participation button in the player profile that says "participate in wars" if clicked; they are put into the mix; however this button cannot be changed except once you are in; you have to stay in for a minimal of one week and if you "opt out of the wars" you cannot participate again for another week like the base attacks if you change legions or leave for a short time to help out another legion. This will discourage players from getting in; finding out they get hit a lot and "don't want to ruin their stats" and run away; then come back to hit a few times and leave and use the "opt out" as a protection against their aggression.

Author:	Preliator Xzien [ Tue May 22, 2012 11:20 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Request new alert rules for Legion Combat
Excelcier wrote: If a player is going after red badges and yellow badges hits a player that doesn't like it and they retaliate; the attacking player now has the ability to alert that player who was originally attacked to his entire legion. So? There'll always be jerks, can't do anything about that. Some of you are assuming that the player being attacked is the only aggressor by stealing a planet or some other type of action. No... this is for all alerts The current alerting system does not allow for an equal type ability to respond. War is never equal It is a one sided response. the alerted can fight back if they want to I am not asking for LESS ability to fight; I am asking for more ability to fight those who want to go at it. then toss a cm at them and you two can go at it how ever long you'd like. alert each other and get the whole legion involved. Yes, there are legions who want to fight each other; there are those who don't. That was why I had the suggestion for "legion wars" tab by an officer or leader of a legion. We want only certain people doing certain things with the legion. Let's even look at the mutual aspect of each side wanting to fight -- If one side "declares war" on the other; have an "accept legion war" by the other side. And if the other side doesn't want to fight? They just decline the war? The simple solution here is that those two legions then only have the other legion on their BT; this would make it an overall minimal change for Dan to make; yes, we would be limited to only 10 on the other side, unless Dan would expand the player participation on the BT screens. The simple solution is to have your legion find one of the other legion on their bt, get alerted and then slowly alert the whole legion until you guys all have each other on your news feed. No need for Dan to add a feature that can easily be worked around already. A solution for those who do not want to participate is also have a participation button in the player profile that says "participate in wars" if clicked; they are put into the mix; however this button cannot be changed except once you are in; you have to stay in for a minimal of one week and if you "opt out of the wars" you cannot participate again for another week like the base attacks if you change legions or leave for a short time to help out another legion. This will discourage players from getting in; finding out they get hit a lot and "don't want to ruin their stats" and run away; then come back to hit a few times and leave and use the "opt out" as a protection against their aggression. Halcyons work too.